Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: https://secure.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/653/10925

From The Socialist newspaper, 12 January 2011

National Shop Stewards Network: Strategy and tactics - a dialogue


[Update 12/1/11 - Bob Crow and Alex Gordon of the RMT, together with Socialist Party members Bill Mullins and Linda Taaffe (Co-Organiser and Secretary of the NSSN), subsequently published a joint statement with which can be read here: Joint statement on NSSN anti-cuts conference]


Transport union RMT general secretary Bob Crow has written, in a personal capacity, to the NSSN and the Socialist Party. Below is his letter and a response from the Socialist Party's executive committee.

An open letter in a personal capacity from RMT general secretary Bob Crow to the National Shop Stewards Network and Socialist Party
Dear brothers and sisters

I am writing to urge maximum unity in the struggle against the Coalition government's austerity programme.

Such is the scale of the onslaught against our class that no one should be in any doubt of the need for such unity.

There can be no question of any political party or organisation seeking to assume leadership of this struggle or setting up new national organisations that would create disunity.

Instead all our efforts should be devoted to mobilising all progressive forces and building the biggest and broadest possible movement against the cuts.

I would urge all comrades to take a step back and consider how we can best act in a way which helps achieve these aims.

Yours in unity
Bob Crow
RMT general secretary

[The Socialist Party subsequently met with Bob Crow and issued this joint statement.]


Response from the Socialist Party's executive committee
Dear Bob,

We welcome your letter as it gives us a chance to discuss the strategy and tactics for the anti-cuts movement with you, which has not been possible up until now. Such an exchange, even if there are differences, can help to clarify these vital issues. We make some initial comments on your letter below, but are looking forward to the meeting that has been arranged between us to further develop the discussion.

What was agreed at the December meeting of the NSSN steering committee to go to the NSSN anti-cuts conference on 22 January? The proposal is quite simple: to establish an NSSN anti-cuts campaign, with the explanatory sub-heading: "Unions and communities together to fight all cuts in jobs and services". And, if that proposal is agreed by NSSN supporters (ie workplace reps) at the conference, to elect a committee (of six trade unionists, four representatives of community campaigns plus the NSSN chair and secretary) to run the campaign.

The myth has been put around that this means 'changing the character' of the NSSN, even its 'dissolution', but when the proposal is looked at soberly this is clearly not the case.

Whatever the outcome of the conference concerning the proposal to set up an anti-cuts campaign, the NSSN will continue to exist with its current constitution, remit, and independent activity. But the proposal to establish an anti-cuts campaign would enable unity to be built between trade unionists and community campaigners in a way the NSSN cannot currently do.

Our hope is that this campaign will bring a new element to the anti-cuts movement in being clearly committed to opposing all cuts to jobs and services including, as the steering committee proposal states: "relentless lobbying of councils and other bodies to persuade them not to vote for cuts".

The Socialist Party has consistently argued for cooperation between the different anti-cuts organisations and we welcome your call for unity, which we share. As with us, we are sure you have a principled approach to this crucial struggle to defend the working class against the government's onslaught.

Not everyone involved in the anti-cuts movement, however, has the same approach that the Socialist Party and the RMT have.

The RMT leadership would rightly oppose calls for 'limited' cuts in rail jobs and services. On the general issue of cuts this principled approach is unfortunately not that adopted by the leadership of the TUC. You rightly criticise them and as a result are sometimes accused of being too intransigent.

We are facing criticism for the same reason. Regrettably, many in the leadership of other anti-cuts campaigns, such as the Coalition of Resistance (CoR), do not oppose all cuts in jobs and services.

While this is their formal position, it was clear at their conference that many in the CoR believed that Labour and Green councillors have no choice but to 'reluctantly' carry out massive cuts in workers' jobs and vital public services.

It is not a coincidence that neither Tony Mulhearn, leader of the struggle of Liverpool city council in the 1980s, nor Ted Knight, leader of Lambeth council, were invited to speak - yet Green councillors who had voted for cuts were. Ted Knight attended the conference and was only allowed to speak from the floor of a workshop.

You state that: "there can be no question of any political party or organisation seeking to assume leadership of this struggle or setting up new national organisations that would create disunity". We agree that no organisation can automatically assume leadership - organisations and programmes will be tested out in the struggle, as is the case in the trade union movement.

However, this is unfortunately not the approach of CoR and Right to Work who have attempted to present themselves as the leadership of the struggle. From our point of view, if a national anti-cuts organisation existed that was determined to fight against all cuts to the end and had a democratic structure which allowed full participation we would happily support it.

This, however, is not the case. At the CoR founding conference, for example, there were 21 platform speakers in the plenary sessions with no opportunity for discussion from the floor. The workshops were also dominated with platform speakers, with over 60 of them speaking in the course of the day. Contrast this with the democracy of the RMT conference or of the NSSN conference which, in the four years of its existence, has always allowed the majority of the time for discussion from the floor.

We agree that one national anti-cuts organisation is desirable if possible, but not if it is dominated by a self-appointed leadership. The NSSN - which the RMT initiated - is not top-down but has a proud record of democratic discussion which we will strive to continue at the anti-cuts conference on 22 January. Whatever the outcome of the conference the Socialist Party remains fully committed to the NSSN and will continue to work to develop it.

We are very willing to discuss the best way forward, and even to seek an accommodation on the basis of a clear programme and organisational perspective for fighting the cuts. However, the political leadership of the anti-cuts struggle cannot be ceded to people who are acting as a left cover for Labour and others that want to carry out cuts at local level, something that you have always opposed.

We believe it is essential that a national anti-cuts body exists which is based on a clear working-class programme, including opposition to all cuts and services. We are very happy to discuss with you how this can best be created.

The Socialist Party executive committee

[Editor's note: Bob Crow and Alex Gordon of the RMT have subsequently published a joint statement with Bill Mullins and Linda Taaffe, Socialist Party members and Co-Organiser and Secretary of the NSSN, which can be read here: Joint statement on NSSN anti-cuts conference]

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 12 January 2011:


Anti-cuts campaign

Bankers get billions - We get cuts


Youth fight for jobs

March for a future - Join the demonstrations on 29 January

More attacks on rights for young workers

Axe falls on courses at UWIC

Students at Leeds Trinity re-occupy


International socialist news and analysis

Tunisia: Wave of protests against repressive regime


National Shop Stewards Network

Rage at inequality fires workers' action

NSSN National: Anti-Cuts Conference

NSSN debate: The way forward for the anti-cuts movement

National Shop Stewards Network: Strategy and tactics - a dialogue

Labour baroness wants politics kept out of the Forest of Dean

Fighting Labour's cuts in Waltham Forest


Socialist Party news and analysis

Jobs cut while the rich carry on partying

The plot thickens at News International

'Big Oil' cuts corners on safety to boost profits

Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition

Councils ramp up service charges

Campaigners tell PM: 'No to Royal Mail privatisation'

Police moles attempt to discredit protest movements


Socialist Party workplace news

Unison rejects NHS pay freeze

Kirklees council: First round victory in cuts battle

Darlington: Newsquest strikes continue to spread

Rotherham teachers strike

Workplace news in brief


 

Home   |   The Socialist 12 January 2011   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  




Related links:

National Shop Stewards Network:

triangleFord Bridgend workers vote to fight to save threatened plant

triangleTrade union action can end low pay

triangleWales NSSN: Support the Ford Bridgend workers - No Closure

triangleSouthampton hospital workers win

triangleFight the closures save every job!

Shop Stewards:

triangleStrike together to kick out the Tories!

triangleWorkplace news in brief

triangleUnited on need for fightback - now keep pressure on for action

triangleVictory for Birmingham bin workers

Socialist Party:

triangleCaerphilly Socialist Party: The threat to the NHS from capitalist trade deals

triangleCaerphilly Socialist Party: Struggles in the USA

triangleCaerphilly Socialist Party: A socialist programme to transform society

Socialist:

triangleBirmingham South East Socialist Party: Corbyn and the working class

triangleManchester: RMT transport workers' conference fringe meeting

Cuts:

triangleUnite must be at the head of fighting for a general election and against council cuts

NSSN:

triangleWorkers discuss action to save Honda jobs

RMT:

triangleBluestar bus drivers' strike over pay

Bob Crow:

triangleReclaim the Game book launch

Coalition of Resistance:

triangleThe NSSN, the anti-cuts struggle and the Trade Unions

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns

19/6/19

South Western Railway

South Western Railway staff strike for safety

19/6/19

Barking

Angry residents' meeting demands answers and action following fire

19/6/19

Ford

Ford Bridgend workers vote to fight to save threatened plant

19/6/19

Southampton

Bluestar bus drivers' strike over pay

19/6/19

Newham

East London bin workers call 12-day strike over wage grades

19/6/19

Swansea

Swansea Parcelforce workers picket depot in support of victimised rep

19/6/19

Harrogate

Harrogate academy workers strike against closure

19/6/19

Orgreave

Orgreave injustice - 35th anniversary march and rally

19/6/19

Newham

Oppose big business's sphere of influence!

19/6/19

Rhondda

Young Socialists - re-establishing Rhondda's fighting traditions

19/6/19

North Shields

North Shields: second march and rally to #SaveOurBridge

19/6/19

NHS

Newton Abbot says no to Tory privatisation of the NHS!

19/6/19

Worcester

Worcester: Building on our successful library campaign

19/6/19

Low pay

Trade union action can end low pay

19/6/19

Climate change

What way forward to tackle climate change?

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

LATEST POSTS

CONTACT US

Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777

Email: info@socialistparty.org.uk

Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551

ABOUT US

ARCHIVE

Alphabetical listing


June 2019

May 2019

April 2019

March 2019

February 2019

January 2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999