Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 4 May 2011

Review: The monarchy - reserve weapon of the ruling class?

Tony Mulhearn, photo Harry Smith

Tony Mulhearn, photo Harry Smith   (Click to enlarge)

BBC Radio 4's The Moral Maze programme recently dealt with the monarchy against a background of the circus surrounding the wedding of Wills and Kate. The question posed was: Is the monarchy compatible with a truly meritocratic society?
The panel included former Tory minister Michael Portillo and right-wing columnist Clifford Longley. Socialist Party member Tony Mulhearn, one of the Liverpool 47 councillors who fought Thatcher's cuts in the 1980s and former president of the Liverpool district Labour Party, appeared as a 'witness'. Here is Tony's account of the debate:
Anti-Monarchy Protesters against the Royal Wedding, photo Paul Mattsson

Anti-Monarchy Protesters against the Royal Wedding, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

The main thrust was that the monarchy was a force for good. Portillo maintained that the monarchy brought 'colour and interest' to people's lives. Longley argued that my 'roundhead' values would provide for a colourless, miserable existence for the masses, as well as maintaining that the monarchy was above class, and above the squalid manoeuvring of politics.

I said that to describe the monarchy as 'above class' was frankly ludicrous; explaining that the queen herself possesses enormous wealth and is the biggest landowner on the planet.

I added that there is no place in a democratic society for an unelected institution which possesses inherited powers.

The UK does not have a written constitution which sets out the rights and duties of the Sovereign, they are established by conventions. These are non-statutory rules which can be just as binding as formal constitutional rules. As a constitutional monarch, theoretically the Sovereign must remain politically neutral.

However, the Sovereign retains an important political role as head of state, formally appointing prime ministers, and approving certain legislation. She has other official roles to play, such as head of the armed forces and head of the police, and can be seen as having two roles: Head of State, and 'Head of the Nation'.

Anti-Monarchy Protesters against the Royal Wedding, photo Paul Mattsson

Anti-Monarchy Protesters against the Royal Wedding, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

In circumstances of a fundamental conflict of interests between capital and labour it is not inconceivable that, under pressure from capitalism, the monarch could refuse to sign an Act which, for instance, nationalised the commanding heights of the economy under workers' control and management.

In November 1975 the Queen's representative Governor-General of Australia, Sir John Kerr, dismissed Labour's Gough Whitlam as prime minister and appointed right-wing Malcolm Fraser as a caretaker prime minister. Thus an unelected vice-regal representative had removed from office a government which commanded a majority in the House of Representatives.

It would be impossible to believe that this action was taken without the approval of the British monarchy. Portillo dismissed this example of Royal political action by first saying it was a civil servant's mistake, then later in the programme saying he didn't believe it. He maintained that societies were fairer in countries where monarchies existed.

Anti-Monarchy Protesters against the Royal Wedding, photo Paul Mattsson

Anti-Monarchy Protesters against the Royal Wedding, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

If time allowed I could have given many other examples of the reactionary role of monarchies.

The Moral Maze did provide a limited platform to explain the class nature of the monarchy, but against the universal sycophancy of the media and the unrivalled ability of the British state to stage an extravagant event at considerable expense to the long-suffering tax payer, it was a peashooter opposing a hostile tank formation.

Great play was made of poll after poll indicating mass support among the population for the continuation of the monarchy. If the wording on such a poll was: 'Do you support an unelected institution having the power to frustrate the will of a democratically elected government' I think we would see a different outcome.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 4 May 2011:

Socialist Party NHS campaign

NHS Cuts: Stop the Con-Dem wreckers

NHS: Stop the Connaught closure

Youth fight for jobs

Join the Jarrow march!

Socialist Party editorial

Cracks grow in Con-Dem coalition

Socialist Party feature

Cuts hit disabled people hard

Socialist Party news and analysis

Review: The monarchy - reserve weapon of the ruling class?

May Day in Kazakhstan marked by attacks on socialists

Coventry residents' victory over Academy land snatch

Fast news

Socialist Party workplace news

More teachers vote for pensions strike ballot

Rotherham teachers strike again to defend their union rep

National Shop Stewards Network

Socialist Party feature

Paris commune 1871: When workers "stormed heaven".

Already posted on the Socialist Party website

Osama Bin Laden - killed by US forces

Socialists elected to leading positions in Greenwich Unite

Solidarity action builds for BP/Vivergo Saltend workers


Home   |   The Socialist 4 May 2011   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:

Royal Family:

triangleEd Balls: 'Speaking Out' for capitalism

triangleBook review: Spy drama gives insight into capitalist coup plot

triangleQueen celebrates longest reign - let's make it the last!

trianglePrivileged perks for Kate and Wills... Maternity cuts for us!

triangleMonarchy - not just a 'harmless relic'


triangleThem & us

triangleDuke's car crash: one law for them and another for us

triangleRoyal wedding opulence... during longest pay squeeze in 200 years

triangleCatalonia: thousands on the streets


triangleBook: The Making of a Liverpool Militant by Tony Mulhearn

triangleTony Mulhearn 1939-2019: Courageous fighter for the working class and socialism

triangleTony Mulhearn 1939-2019


trianglePCS union - A reply on political strategy

triangleMass union mobilisation needed to counter anti-choice group

Tony Mulhearn:

triangleThe Socialist Inbox


triangleEast London Socialist Party: The state - a warning to Corbynism


triangleTories out - general election now

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments



Major new book out in November: In Defence of Trotskyism


David Cameron

The Cameron Tory legacy


Tony Mulhearn

Book: The Making of a Liverpool Militant by Tony Mulhearn



Film review: Joker - Sympathising with a monster created by today's incendiary conditions


Sexual harassment

Book review: She Said - Breaking the Sexual Harassment Story That Helped Ignite a Movement



The Socialist inbox


Socialist Party

Active and strong member of Socialist Party reaches 80



The Socialist Inbox



The Socialist inbox



Peterloo - fighting for democracy and a better life



Capitalist 'democracy' v socialist democracy



At 96 I'm more convinced of socialism than ever



The Socialist Inbox



The Socialist Inbox



Knife and gun crime a product of poverty and austerity

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07954 376 096

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

October 2019

September 2019

August 2019

July 2019

June 2019

May 2019

April 2019

March 2019

February 2019

January 2019