Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: https://secure.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/684/12732

From The Socialist newspaper, 7 September 2011

Book review

Them and Us by Will Hutton

Then and Us - Will Hutton, photo Abacus (publisher)

  (Click to enlarge)

'Them and Us' by former Observer editor Will Hutton, originally published in 2010, is now available in paperback. Bob Severn reviews the book.

The title Them and Us suggests a combative book about the poor versus rich - unfortunately it is not. The book's focus is really its subtitle, Changing Britain - Why We Need a Fair Society, by which the author, Will Hutton, means a fair capitalist society.

'Them', according to Hutton, are "the financial plutocrats, incumbent corporate power and the networks of the super-rich". So the rest of 'us' includes the 'nicer' capitalists. While he condemns the 'unproductive' capitalists, and the greed of the bankers, with plenty of evidence, Hutton pins his hopes on 'productive capitalism'.

He wants another industrial revolution, and 'another Enlightenment', for the 'knowledge economy'. He wants more Alan Sugars, James Dysons and Richard Bransons. So more anti-union 'entrepreneurs', whose expertise includes driving down wages?

Big manufacturers are currently sitting on piles of cash. However, instead of investing in production, they are using that cash on the money markets due to "uncertainty over demand". Hutton disapproves but what alternative is he putting?

Hutton likes trade unions - except when they fight for their members! For example, he attacks print unions including journalists in the NUJ for practicing closed shops: "By the mid-1980s, the print unions were abusing their power with scandalous working practices, and obstructing the introduction of digital technology".

This repeats, like elsewhere in the book, the capitalist media's anti-union propaganda and mistruths.

Yet, in barely the next breath, Hutton quotes from Nick Davies, writer of Flat Earth News, [reviewed in the Socialist 679 - Eds] saying: "Twenty years later, Davies's researchers calculated that a falling payroll of national journalists was writing three times more copy every year to fill ever more sections and magazines as the great titles competed for market share."

The 'power abuse' Hutton speaks of was actually defending jobs and conditions - not holding back technology, but trying to stop Murdoch using technology to sack workers, cut pay and attack workers' organisation.

Hutton doesn't want fighting trade unions, he wants consultative professional associations.

Hutton also condemns the' third way' of Blair and New Labour, for giving too much power to the private sector. Yet, to me, the book puts forward a third way revisited, ie, a marriage of the public and private sector.

He says there's a need for Keynesian pump-priming to help the economy into recovery. He says all three main parties' cuts plans are based on contentious growth predictions.

Hutton thinks that Labour's capital spending cuts (school building, road building etc), which the Con-Dems are now implementing, will be disastrous. But he also says that cuts are needed, just not as fast or as brutal as the Con-Dem government's plans.

For example, Hutton thinks we should pay for all services in the NHS, apart from urgent treatment, unless we're very poor. University fees must rise, he says, but state school students should get a big discount.

But what about the 120 billion of tax unpaid by the rich, which equals the figure that Hutton gives for the needed deficit reduction? Of course, the rich would not hand over this money voluntarily, and any real threat to their wealth would be answered with a strike of capital.

This is why these parasitic tax dodgers' resources should be put under public ownership and democratic control with compensation paid only on the basis of proven need. Then this wealth could be used to benefit all of society, instead of benefitting a few while the rest of us pay the cost.

Hutton's book is full of the crimes of the financial sector, the last New Labour government and the Tories. However, do not pin your hopes on the 'nice' capitalists, you're better off fighting for jobs and services, as shown in the Socialist.


Buy Will Hutton's Them and Us from Socialist Books at www.socialistbooks.org.uk

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 7 September 2011:


Action to defeat the cuts!

Strike together to defend pensions

Mobilise the power of the working class


The Socialist editorial

Mass workers' movement - the only way to make the super-rich pay


Socialist Party news and analysis

Tory bribes to promote socially divisive 'Free Schools' agenda

NHS reaches a tipping point

Reject health bill attacks on abortion

The riots, Clarke and the "broken penal system"

Fast news

New pamphlet - The Rise and Fall of the Scottish Socialist Party

Miliband to bury Labour


Socialist Party feature

Consequences of 9/11: a world turned upside down


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Bristol marches against home care sell-off

EDL kept out of Tower Hamlets by thousands protesting

Stop the Dale Farm evictions

Confronting a Labour cutter


Socialist Party workplace news

Scotland - Unison calls for pensions strike

Picket lines at police stations

Workplace News in brief


Socialist Party youth and students

Youth March For Jobs

One in a million...fighting back!

NEET figures still rising

Local Housing Allowance

36,000 for a degree


Socialist Party review

Them and Us by Will Hutton


International socialist news and analysis

Libya after Gaddafi - Independent workers' action needed

Indian high commission protest over Tamil death sentences


 

Home   |   The Socialist 7 September 2011   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  




Related links:

Economy:

triangleState intervention shows what is possible

triangleBirmingham South East Socialist Party: What would a socialist economy look like?

triangleCoronavirus: socialist planning, not capitalist chaos!

triangleCapitalist crisis and Corona: Johnson's budget for the bosses

triangleNationalise to save jobs threatened by Covid-19 and downturn

Unions:

triangleThe self-employed need 100% of their income, and now!

triangleUnion independence must be maintained - a reply to the TUC

triangleBirmingham South East Socialist Party: How important are trade unions today?

triangleStoke council unions beat pay cuts - now let's stop all cuts

Rich:

triangleImmigration: For a system that meets the needs of the majority, not a rich elite

triangleThe rich fund the Tories and Blairites, so help fund the working-class fightback

triangleThem & Us

Cuts:

triangleNewham campaign set up against council cuts and tax hikes

triangleCouncils must break austerity rules

Britain:

triangleWindrush deportations: end the hostile environment

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments

25/3/20

Letters

Going viral: Socialist letters and comments on the coronavirus crisis

18/3/20

TV

TV: Noughts and Crosses

18/3/20

Coronavirus

Going viral: socialist letters and comments on the coronavirus crisis

11/3/20

Women

Women's rights, trans rights and the labour movement

11/3/20

Film

Film: Greed directed by Michael Winterbottom

11/3/20

Len McCluskey

Book: Why you should be a trade unionist by Unite general secretary Len McCluskey

11/3/20

The Socialist

The Socialist Inbox

11/3/20

Childcare

Childcare - costly, inadequate and hard work

4/3/20

The Socialist

The Socialist Inbox

4/3/20

Socialist Party

Why I joined the Socialist Party: I resent the 1% and the system that allows them to exist

26/2/20

The Socialist

The Socialist Inbox

19/2/20

Film

Brilliant Korean film exposes class inequality

12/2/20

BBC

New BBC series - Insight or whitewash?

5/2/20

Liverpool

Liverpool council: "No more cuts" - Is Joe Anderson serious?

5/2/20

Socialist

Socialist Inbox

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

LATEST POSTS

CONTACT US

Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777

Email: info@socialistparty.org.uk

Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 079 8202 1969

East Mids: 077 3797 8057

London: 07748 534 891

North East: 078 4114 4890

North West 079 5437 6096

South West: 077 5979 6478

Southern: 078 3368 1910

Wales: 079 3539 1947

West Mids: 024 7655 5620

Yorkshire: 077 0671 0041

ABOUT US

ARCHIVE

Alphabetical listing


March 2020

February 2020

January 2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999