Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 2 May 2012

Social dumping won't solve the housing crisis

Labour-run Newham council in east London decided recently to try to uproot 500 local families and dump them in Stoke, 160 miles away! Tory Westminster council also wants to kick out poor tenants. Britain's housing crisis is getting deeper. Andy Bentley of Stoke Socialist Party comments.

Newham is one of London's poorest boroughs. 25% of its children live in poverty, according to Save the Children, while billions of pounds are being spent on the nearby Olympic Park.

Newham council asked Brighter Futures Housing Association in Stoke-on-Trent to find homes for up to 500 families who are suffering from the housing benefit cap imposed by the government. But if government cuts continue. these families would find no 'brighter future' in Stoke or any other part of Britain.

Officially Stoke has over 3,000 individuals or families waiting for social housing but the real figure is much higher. Youth unemployment is at 22% and child poverty stands at 19%.

Stoke's Labour council demolished hundreds of good homes but the money has run out to build the replacement homes they promised. The council has built just 17 council bungalows since 1987! 35 million of cuts to jobs and services were carried out last year with another 24 million both this year and next.

The government cuts housing benefit and tries to blame tenants for claiming more to pay their rent! But it's only the landlords charging high rents that gain. Cutting housing benefit hits not just unemployed people - 80% of those claiming housing benefit in London are working.

The number of people officially registered as homeless rose by at least 14% in the last year. Nationally five million people, two million households, are desperate for social housing. Homelessness, high rents and lack of decent affordable social housing is a national problem that can't be solved by 'social dumping'. What is needed is a mass building programme of high quality, affordable council houses.

From 1949 to 1954, 230,000 council houses were built on average every year. A similar building programme today would provide work for hundreds of thousands of unemployed building workers, and also immediately cut the amount of money paid to private landlords in housing benefit.

It could also provide proper apprenticeships for thousands of unemployed young people to train as the next generation of bricklayers, joiners, electricians, plumbers etc. It could be paid for by collecting the 120 billion unpaid corporation tax that big business don't pay every year!

In the past even Tory governments, under mass pressure from the working class, supported a mass house building programme. Instead of trying to 'export' a 'local problem' to another area, Newham Labour council's time would be better spent linking with such a fightback and calling on other Labour councils like Stoke's to do the same.

Spectacular 'free market' failure

Private rents in Newham rose by over 150% over the last five years and one in three households in the borough is on the council house waiting list. In 2009, 28,629 households were on the waiting list. The charity Shelter said this would take 24 years to clear so long as no one else was added to it!

Since then the housing situation has got worse, ironically after the council's clampdown on slum landlords who had profited from renting out garden sheds and ramshackle buildings to poor people.

Newham council, like other local authorities, is not building new homes for affordable rents. And with the construction industry in a slump, neither is the private sector. The number of new housing starts in Britain is the lowest since the 1920s.

Relying for housing on the 'free market' has been championed by successive governments since Thatcher's days. Clearly, it has spectacularly failed working class people.

Simon Carter, Newham

Are we living in the 19th century?

I am a candidate for TUSC in Winchester and a working class mother of three children. I am on less than income support every week to feed my children and recently due to a major accident my son has had I have to spend over 30 of this amount a week to go to hospital and back.

Tonight I read the ideas of the other parties standing in Winchester. The one that hit me most was the Labour candidate who suggested we deal with the homeless problem by putting families in spare attics in the city.

Are we living in the 19th century? Let's just put people in cellars, several families to a room! Do they really expect the working class to believe this hype or are they preaching to rich people who would like to see the poor disappear so they do not have to deal with them anymore?

Adele Guntrip

Needed - new and affordable homes now!

A London housing worker

Newham council's proposals highlight the severe lack of reasonably priced housing in London. Many councils enthusiastically promoted the Tories' so-called 'Right to Buy' laws; all of them failed to build new homes. So now they all rely substantially on the private sector to meet housing need. Newham shows that this approach has failed.

In April 2011 the Con-Dems introduced Local Housing Allowance (LHA - private sector housing benefit) caps of 250 a week (1 bed), 290 (2 bed), 340 (3 bed) and 400 (4 bed or more). They also reduced the benchmark for LHA from average rents to the bottom 30% of rents.

London workers on average wages find it impossible to obtain housing in many parts of the city. In particular, households who are forced out of more central areas put pressure on the supply of private sector rented housing in many outlying areas.

With thousands in temporary accommodation, councils such as Newham are reduced to desperate measures. Newham did not just approach a landlord in Stoke, they approached 1,178 others!

To make matters worse, the Con-Dems nationally, with local councils' cooperation, are raising council and housing association (HA) rents to close to market rents. They also intend only to increase LHA once a year, in line with the Consumer Prices Index, so when private rents increase LHA will not keep up and low paid workers will have to make up the shortfall.

The Con-Dems also intend to introduce a Universal Credit Cap on benefits at 500 which will reduce the money many households who lose employment have for rent to well below market rents. Labour supports the principle of caps on benefits.

Divide and rule

Young people fare even worse. Single under-35s will be expected to share accommodation. A new 'bedroom tax', being introduced shortly, will penalise council and HA tenants who have a spare bedroom through a cut in housing benefit.

Rather than face up to this crisis of their own making, right-wing politicians seek to divide and rule by making false claims about priority being given to new immigrants to obtain council and HA tenancies.

In reality these tenancies are severely rationed for all applicants and almost all will be on waiting lists for years without being successful. Only eligible applicants in severest need will succeed. So people are forced to rely on the perils of private landlords - an option which the Con-Dems are even trying to deny them.

Nancy Taaffe, a Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition (TUSC) candidate in the London elections has pointed out that if the Olympic village was used for social housing after the election it would be more than big enough to house the people Newham want to move to Stoke. But no establishment parties have any answer to the housing crisis.

Rent caps should be introduced immediately to make private sector properties affordable. Councils should give their environmental health sections the resources to take action against landlords of dangerous properties. Legal aid should be available to help tenants enforce their rights. Council and HA rents should be no more than 100 a week.

Most importantly a large programme of new building of genuinely affordable housing is needed urgently. Trade unions should actively campaign on housing issues. A good first step would be to support the Londoners Forced Out campaign (website just launched by Youth Fight for Jobs.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 2 May 2012:

Fighting the government attacks

Kick out the Con-Dems and end austerity

A strategy to stop austerity and bring down the government of the super-rich

Fight privatisation: Save our libraries

National Shop Stewards Network 6th annual conference

Socialist Party news and analysis

Rich list: The good times roll for the 0.00001%

Leveson exposes links between Tories and Murdoch

Them & Us

Socialist Students

NUS conference Support for left and for action

Housing crisis

Social dumping won't solve the housing crisis

Socialist Party feature

Don't accept the misery of austerity

Socialist Party workplace news

Unison leadership 'woefully inadequate' in face of cuts

Rotherham teachers stand up to bullying

Bilborough College Nottingham strike Action over five-term years

UCU joins 10 May strike - student solidarity needed

Workplace news in brief

Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition feature

TUSC: the electoral alternative to the parties of the rich

Socialist Party campaigns

Thug attack won't stop anti-racist work

Socialist MEP discusses way forward for Tamils struggle

Sheffield marches against sexism and cuts

International socialist news and analysis

Capitalist crisis: 'Up to half of all Icelandic families are bankrupt'

Kazakhstan: Socialists jailed by regime

Environment and socialism

The government's fractured energy policy

Planning for the Planet


Home   |   The Socialist 2 May 2012   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   PDF  

Related links:


triangleUnite housing branch supports stand of Enfield councillor

triangleEast London Socialist Party: Election 2019 - fighting for housing for all

triangleCardiff East Socialist Party: The solution to the housing crisis

triangle1 million cuts plan: Peabody housing workers announce strike ballot

triangleLabour's mass social housing pledge


triangleNorth London Socialist Party: How can Corbyn's policies be implemented?

triangleBarking: protest brings pledge to remove dangerous decking

triangleDouble-dealing Hackney council bosses face renewed strike action

triangleThe Socialist inbox


triangleNewham housing repairs workers announce strike dates

triangleOppose big business's sphere of influence!

triangleEast London bin workers call 12-day strike over wage grades


triangleHousing - bold, socialist measures necessary

triangleActivists rally in fight for more council housing and against high rents


triangleSelling the Socialist in Stoke


triangleEast London Socialist Party: After the general election - what now?

Housing benefit:

triangleHousing arrears double, suicide risk soars - scrap Universal Credit!


triangleThem & Us

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis



Save education - Kick out the Tories


Green Party

Green Party offers no alternative for young people and climate change chaos


General election

Strike, Protest, Vote - to Kick the Tories out



High Court injunction: solidarity to the CWU - support the posties!



NHS in critical condition


Labour Party

Labour MP targeted by right wing stands as independent


General election

Attacks show elite fear a Corbyn election win



Tories out! Corbyn in with anti-austerity and socialist policies


Grenfell Tower

Grenfell fire inquiry spin deflects blame from establishment


General election

General election 2019 round-up


Tony Blair

Tony Blair launches manifesto to sabotage a Corbyn government


Black history

Black Liberation... Only possible through socialist struggle


General election

Tories out now! Bin Boris



39 migrants found dead in Essex lorry container



Argos Christmas bonus cut

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07954 376 096

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

November 2019

October 2019

September 2019

August 2019

July 2019

June 2019

May 2019

April 2019

March 2019

February 2019

January 2019