Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: https://secure.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/935/24406

From The Socialist newspaper, 8 February 2017

Non-fiction review: Lenin on the Train

Tense, lively prologue to events which changed the world

Vladimir Lenin, one of the central leaders of the 1917 Russian revolution, photo by German Federal Archive (Creative Commons)

Vladimir Lenin, one of the central leaders of the 1917 Russian revolution, photo by German Federal Archive (Creative Commons)   (Click to enlarge)

Niall Mulholland

When the February revolution broke out in Russia in 1917 and the Tsar was overthrown, Vladimir Lenin was living in exile in Switzerland.

Given his implacable opposition to the imperialist World War One, it was always going to be a major feat for the Bolshevik leader to return to Russia across countries at war, to lead the principled socialist opposition to the new capitalist Provisional Government.

In 'Lenin on the Train', Catherine Merridale gives a lively narrative of Lenin's efforts to get back to revolutionary Russia - "a journey that changed the world" - despite her condemnation of the Bolsheviks once they were in power.

She brings out the crucial role of Lenin, from abroad and on return to Russia, in politically re-orientating the Bolsheviks, so that they were able to go on to lead millions of workers, soldiers and poor peasants and take power in October.

Caught unawares

The Tsarist regime and British diplomatic sources were largely caught unawares by the February revolution, which broke out over food shortages and as seemingly endless war exacted a huge death toll. And they were in denial.

"The striking feature of the British diplomatic and intelligence correspondence at this point was its refusal to accept the finality (let alone legitimacy) of the February Revolution as a whole," Merridale notes.

Lenin urgently looked for a way back to Russia and explored several options. He was approached indirectly by the notorious intriguer and former Marxist thinker, Alexander Helphand (also known as Parvus), who suggested striking a deal with the German regime to allow Lenin and other socialists to return to Russia in a 'sealed' train across German territory.

The German generals, looking over their shoulders as the USA prepared to enter the war, gambled that the return of Lenin and other revolutionaries would worsen Russia's turmoil, forcing the country out of the war. They got much more than they bargained for - a socialist revolution in Russia which inspired the overthrow of the Kaiser and a revolution which threatened the existence of German capitalism.

Merridale shows how Lenin was extremely hesitant about taking up this offer, as he correctly feared it would be used by his political enemies to denounce him as a "German agent." But faced with no other viable option to get back to Russia, Lenin very reluctantly went along with the scheme.

However, he insisted at all times on his full political independence from German imperialism and its interests.

Lenin continued to write and publicly speak on how he opposed all the imperialist warring nations, including Russia and Germany.

He insisted the revolutionaries travelled by third-class coach in the train and that a chalk line drawn across the floor of the carriage separated the Russians from their German military 'minders'.

Merridale discusses in detail the allegation made by Lenin's enemies in 1917, and ever since, that he received "German gold". She concludes that "instead of proof there were only probabilities and lies" to back up this claim which is used to try to discredit Lenin and the Bolsheviks, and to airbrush the role of the masses in the revolution.

Furthermore, she comments that Lenin was no more an agent of imperialism than Georgi Plekhanov, the 'father of Russian Marxism', who was sent back to Russia with the aid of imperialist Britain. For Plekhanov, "though a Marxist, was a sound man on the war, a patriot who could tell other socialists exactly where their duty lay."

As well as the Provisional Government, the February revolution threw up the soviet (council) of workers' deputies, a "dual power" rivalling the capitalist administration. But on the day Lenin's train pulled out of Zurich station, 27 March, the Provisional Government declared, with "an endorsement in the name of the soviet," it would continue the war.

Lenin insisted that the Bolsheviks must resolutely oppose the treacherous Mensheviks and Socialist Revolutionaries at that time leading the soviets.

Merridale describes Lenin's growing exasperation with the vacillating leadership of the Bolsheviks in Russia, particularly Kamenev and Stalin. In the pages of the party paper, Pravda, Kamenev argued that Russia "would still have to fight and win its war, albeit mainly to defend the gains of the revolution..."

Although Kamenev was "censored" by the local party ("and Stalin silently abandoned him"), confusion reigned inside the Bolsheviks until Lenin's return. Lenin's "telegram of early March had been explicit: no support for the Provisional Government, no cooperation with other parties... for a transfer of power from the bourgeois to a workers' militia or to soviets...

"The whole line ruled out any coalition with the Mensheviks. The war, he had insisted, was a bloody capitalist adventure, and not what Kerensky was now calling a fight for revolutionary self-defence."

Jubilant

On reaching Finland Station, Petrograd, Lenin told a large jubilant crowd to prepare for socialist revolution. "His slogans felt like a sudden electric shock... a call to life, a blinding glimpse of futures some had privately begun to doubt," Merridale writes.

The last chapter brings out Merridale's political hostility towards Lenin. She claims the October revolution was a "coup" that led to "dictatorship." In doing so, Merridale dismisses a genuine revolution involving millions and conflates the early years of working class rule with later Stalinist counter-revolutionary tyranny.

Nevertheless, the fact remains that the October revolution marked the first time the working class came to power successfully and started to carry out the socialist transformation of society against enormous odds.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 8 February 2017:


Southern Rail dispute

Stand with the RMT: unite against Southern Rail and the Tories

Southern dispute: Aslef members must reject offer

Southern dispute: disappointment and anger - RMT president responds


Socialism not Trumpism

#NoBanNoWall #ResistTrump: Solidarity not racism - socialism not Trumpism


Socialist Party news and analysis

SNP and Greens agree cuts budget in Scotland


Save our NHS!

No cuts, no closures, save our NHS!

NHS: fight for funding - not passport checks


Universal Basic Income

Universal basic income - what do socialists say?


Socialist Party workplace news

RMT wins important tube jobs and grading victory

London Midland victory: RMT forces bosses to withdraw outsourced security

BA strike: "We're being paid well below what we should be"

AWE pension strikers vow to fight on

Workplace news in brief


International socialist news and analysis

Syria: Is an end to the war in sight?

Romania: mass protests against corruption go on


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Support Cardiff's no-cuts three

Campaign forces Surrey council to back down on fire station closure

Southampton: no-cuts budget needed

Regional Socialist Party conferences

Make some noise for Orgreave!

Canterbury Socialist Party attends 'I, Daniel Blake' film night


Socialist Party comments and reviews

Tense, lively prologue to events which changed the world

Smearing socialism by attacking the arts

The Socialist Inbox


 

Home   |   The Socialist 8 February 2017   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook






Related links:

Review:

triangleFiction: Tombland "The power of common people fighting for justice in the 16th century"

triangleTheatre review: Women of Aktion - the heroic story of how World War One was ended

triangle'Lucas Plan' film tells story of workers who set out alternative to job losses

triangleEnthusiastic response to new podcast

triangleDetermined UCU strikers: We're out to win!

Lenin:

triangleHeroic martyrs of German Revolution

triangleBirmingham Central Socialist Party: Lenin's book 'State and Revolution'

triangleLeeds Socialist Party: The ideas of Lenin

triangleStriking analysis in heat of 1917 will deepen any reader's understanding

Russia:

triangleSupport for Putin's regime dips over major attacks on state pensions

triangleThem & us

triangleThe Socialist inbox

Revolution:

triangle40 years since the Iranian revolution: Learning the lessons for today's new working-class struggles

triangleHackney & Islington Socialist Party: Reform or Revolution?

Socialist:

triangleYouth strike for the climate: "There's no planet B"

Bolsheviks:

triangleWell-deserved ridicule of Stalinism is impressive, funny but flawed

Capitalist:

triangleCorbyn must prepare for a general election

Marxist:

triangleLeicester East Socialist Party: What is Marxist Economics?

Imperialism:

triangleCaerphilly Socialist Party: Venezuela - for a real socialist alternative to corruption and imperialism

Stalin:

triangleBirmingham Socialist Party: The struggle against Stalin

Britain:

triangleNorth West Socialist Party conference

Marxism:

triangleManchester Socialist Party: Marxism & Identity Politics

Council:

triangleVictory to Birmingham bin workers

Bourgeois:

triangleRussia, October 1917: When workers took power

Food:

triangleWest London Xmas party

Germany:

triangleSwansea Socialist Party1919: When Germany was on the brink of socialism

Switzerland:

triangleDavos summit: a broken capitalist system

The Socialist:

triangleManchester Socialist Party: The record of the Socialist Party

USA:

triangle'Green Book' film: a timely reminder of racism in the USA

Socialist Books:

triangle'Socialism: Utopian and Scientific'

Russian:

triangleInternational round-up

Independence:

triangleCatalonia: 1m marchers demand self-determination

Parties:

triangleProtests continue to rage in Sudan

Aid:

triangleNo to fat-cat top judges' 59k pay hike - fight for decent pay for criminal justice workers

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments

13/2/19

Letters

The Socialist inbox

13/2/19

NHS

'Secret Diaries of a Junior Doctor': comedy and tragedy judiciously mixed

13/2/19

Film

'Green Book' film: a timely reminder of racism in the USA

6/2/19

Theatre

Theatre: Ballad of Johnny Longstaff

6/2/19

Letters

The Socialist inbox

6/2/19

Film

Film: Vice - Dick Cheney - a cold and calculating opportunist

30/1/19

Review

Fiction: Tombland "The power of common people fighting for justice in the 16th century"

30/1/19

Letters

The Socialist Inbox

30/1/19

Exhibition

Exhibition: Anglo-Saxon Kingdoms: Art, Word, War

23/1/19

Letters

The Socialist inbox

23/1/19

Theatre

Theatre: Rouse, Ye Women to tell story of 1910 chainmakers' strike

23/1/19

Rosa Luxemburg

Non-fiction: The Murder of Rosa Luxemburg "reveals the brutal lengths capitalists will go to protect their system"

16/1/19

Letters

The Socialist Inbox

16/1/19

EU

Brexit: The Uncivil War - an interesting but inaccurate portrayal of EU referendum

16/1/19

Film

Sorry to Bother You: "Socialist film Botox that made me feel young again"

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

LATEST POSTS

CONTACT US

Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777

Email: info@socialistparty.org.uk

Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551

ABOUT US

ARCHIVE

Alphabetical listing


February 2019

January 2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999