Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 19 January 2022

Why are things the way they are?

Leon Trotsky resolutely defended 'scientific socialism', or Marxism, and applied these ideas to develop the socialist movement internationally

Leon Trotsky resolutely defended 'scientific socialism', or Marxism, and applied these ideas to develop the socialist movement internationally   (Click to enlarge)

In the first of a series on Marxist classics, Nick Hart reviews 'An introduction to the Logic of Marxism' by George Novack.

In 'The Logic of Marxism', George Novack attempts to answer this question often posed by philosophers, scientists and small children alike. This short book is based on a series of talks delivered in 1942 to worker activists in the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) in America (not to be confused with the present-day British organisation of the same name).

At the time, the SWP was a leading section of the Fourth International. This followed the Third International, a global organisation of communist parties which grew rapidly during the turbulent period of the 1920s as workers were inspired by the example of the October 1917 Russian Revolution.

Despite this, the leadership of the Third International, which after Lenin's death in 1924 increasingly came under the control of Stalin and his bureaucratic clique, passed up multiple revolutionary opportunities, which helped lead to the rise of fascism and World War Two.

Therefore, the Russian revolutionary socialist Leon Trotsky (who was expelled from Russia and the Communist Party by Stalin) and his supporters, including the SWP, set up the Left Opposition and then the Fourth International to resist the turn of the USSR away from a democratically run workers' state during the 1920s and 30s, and to reorient the workers' movement internationally to the socialist revolution.

Sudden turns

Then as now, it was a time of sharp turns in the political and economic situation, old certainties collapsing and things seemingly being transformed into their opposite.

Like today, it was necessary for revolutionaries to understand not only what was happening and why, but what direction political groups, classes and society as a whole were heading, so as not to be caught by surprise by apparently sudden turns in events.

The Logic of Marxism was written to aid this by summarising the philosophical discoveries of Marx and Engels in an accessible form, with examples given based on the political struggles of the time.

Novack begins by explaining how the Ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle developed the system of formal logic. Put simply, these laws of identity state that each thing, be it object, living being or concept, is entirely itself, and is not and cannot be what it isn't.

Clearly this approach has practical uses in telling apart one thing from another. A hammer is not a screwdriver, up is not down, and a capitalist is not a worker.

But while formal logic can tell us what something is and is not at any given moment in time, what it can't describe is how it came to be the way it is, what it will be in the future, and the internal and external forces leading to these changes.

In the late 18th century these limitations of formal logic were taken up by the German philosopher Georg Hegel.

As Novack describes, this took place against the backdrop of the French and American revolutions, where "the whole of civilised society was racked by contradictory forces and turned upside down. These colossal, catastrophic conflicts impressed themselves upon minds and turned them upside down too."

New philosophy

Hegel reformulated the system of logic and thinking known as 'dialectics'. This holds that rather than each thing having a permanent "identity" within a definite category, objects, organisms or social groupings can contain multiple contradictory characteristics, and over time transform into something else - even their opposite. And all things that come into being will eventually cease to exist.

As Novack comments, "nothing is permanent. Reality is never resting, ever changeable, always in flux." He gives the example of how a seed can grow into a tree which bears flowers and fruit which in turn contains more seeds. All of these are distinct and different things, but all contain elements of each other.

In the same way, an economic boom in capitalism can store up problems which lead to a slump, a period of seeming political stability can lay the basis for revolution, and a former workers' party can become a party of big business.

At the time, this system of dialectics was revolutionary. Taken to its logical conclusion, it challenged the prevailing ideas that the world is, and always has been, as God created it, and that there will always be rich and poor as part of the natural order of things. No wonder that Marx and Engels found these ideas energising, with both of them participating in meetings of the Young Hegelians while students.

However, as the book goes on to explain, the main flaw in Hegel's dialectics was that he believed that it was ideas that dictate the world around us, and that the motor force behind changes in human society is a combination of "world-spirit", "national-spirit" and "the spirit of the times". But this is clearly back to front.

A seed grows into a plant not because it is inherently destined to, but because of the sun and rain acting upon it. The early capitalist class didn't set out to overturn the previous system of feudalism, but found that capitalist methods of production represented the best way for them to enrich themselves.

Dialectical materialism

Marx and Engels' great philosophical breakthrough was to take Hegel's dialectical method and to make it materialist.

Engels summed it up: "Human beings must first of all eat, drink, shelter and clothe themselves before they can turn their attention to politics, science, art and religion." In other words, all ideas flow from material reality, and not the other way round.

Giving the example of a car worker who gets drawn into struggle against his bosses' attempts to attack pay and conditions, Novack shows how it is experience of reality and conditions of day-to-day living that exert the greatest influence on people's view of the world.

Formal logic will tell us that something is either true, or false. But dialectics helps us to see how a false idea can grow from a grain of truth.

Religion, for example, partly grew out of a need to explain the changing of the seasons and to organise ancient society. And today's conspiracy theorists offer ready-made and made-up explanations for the problems faced by ordinary people, while only scratching the surface of the real economic and class interests that govern capitalist society.

Similarly, liberals and conservatives alike raise 'common sense' to the level of a science standing above society and governing human relations for all of time.

But what is considered 'common sense' varies from one era to the next, and one class to the next. A pay cut will appear logical to the boss trying to protect their bottom line, but less so to the worker expected to do the same amount of work for less money!

Most importantly of all, Novack explains how the Marxist form of 'scientific socialism' isn't just an abstract idea based on what is morally right, but grew out of the economic reality of capitalism itself. If capitalism can create a working class which is vital to production and the running of society, and are concentrated together in factories and chains of production, then it follows that this same working class would do a better job of managing production and society than the capitalists who leech off them.

But although societal changes and revolutions will have a basis in the already existing social and economic state of society, the passing over from capitalism to socialism won't be inevitable. "As Marx and Engels pointed out, ideas become forces when the masses accept them".

The role of a Marxist party is to take the method of dialectical materialism developed over centuries, and use the understanding it gives us of the world we live in to build a movement that can change it.

As Novack puts it at the book's conclusion: "The abolition of capitalism through the triumph of socialism will be the final vindication of the logic of Marxism. The task of revolutionary socialists is to realise this in life."

The Logic of Marxism by George Novack

Published by Pathfinder. Currently unavailable at Left Books. Used copies widely available online

Also, In Defence of Marxism by Leon Trotsky

£22, including postage, available from Left Books -

A robust defence of Marxist philosophy during a factional fight within the US section of the Fourth International in 1939-40.

Donate to the Socialist Party

Finance appeal

The coronavirus crisis has laid bare the class character of society in numerous ways. It is making clear to many that it is the working class that keeps society running, not the CEOs of major corporations.

The results of austerity have been graphically demonstrated as public services strain to cope with the crisis.

  • The Socialist Party's material is more vital than ever, so we can continue to report from workers who are fighting for better health and safety measures, against layoffs, for adequate staffing levels, etc.
  • We must be ready for the stormy events ahead and the need to arm workers' movements with a socialist programme - one which puts the health and needs of humanity before the profits of a few.
Inevitably, during the crisis we have not been able to sell the Socialist and raise funds in the ways we normally would.
We therefore urgently appeal to all our viewers to donate to our Fighting Fund.

Please donate here.

All payments are made through a secure server.

My donation


Your message: 


In The Socialist 19 January 2022:

What we think

Tories on the ropes


Want to fight austerity?

No trust in Tories to keep us safe

Tories hand cash to private health profiteers

Tory vaccine sacking threat set to deepen NHS staffing crisis

Employers use vaccine excuse to attack sick pay

News in brief

International news

Murder of Ashling Murphy sends shocks waves across Ireland and beyond

Northern Ireland: Workers fight threatened closure of women's hostel

US: Independent Socialist Group launches new paper

Eyewitness account of workers' uprising in Almaty, Kazakhstan

Public services

Mutual aid, the welfare state and the fight for a new mass workers' party

Marxist classics

Why are things the way they are?

Rob Windsor

Rob Windsor - remembering a tireless fighter for socialism


Theatre: Yes Yes UCS

Workplace news

Sheffield Just Eat couriers speak about strike

S Yorks Stagecoach strike results in "huge pay win"

Scunthorpe scaffs resume indefinite strike action

Coventry bin strike continues

Bus driver Tracey Scholes reinstated at Go North West

Royal Mail: Unofficial walkouts precede bigger battle to come on pay and workload

Newham college strike solid against bully privatisers

Somers Forge workers continue pay strike

Workplace news in brief


NUS walkout: Organise to fight for free education on 2 March

Demonstrating against the Tory anti-protest bill

Waltham Forest: Campaign unites families facing eviction

Newham council rejects using 0.03% of reserves to fund arts

Birmingham: Cuts consultations replaced by computer game

Southampton uni ignores staff and students in exam farce

Oliver Campbell - 31 years fighting for justice

Bournemouth - angry people not represented by capitalist parties

Pauline Wall memorial meeting


Home   |   The Socialist 19 January 2022   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook

Related links:


triangleHackney & Islington Socialist Party: How to fight council cuts

triangleSouthampton Socialist Party: Marxist economics

triangleBrighton Socialist Party: What is Marxism?

triangleCaerphilly and RCT Socialist Party: What is Marxism?

triangleCardiff West Socialist Party: What is Marxism?


triangleUkraine: Workers' unity against capitalist warmongers and imperialist meddlers

triangleThe Socialist: 25 years of assisting workers' struggles and fighting for socialism

triangleDave Nellist talking with striking bin workers in Birmingham. Dave is standing for TUSC in the 3 March Erdington byelection. Click for details to help or donate.

triangleVictory at NewVIc college! 'The picket line gives us power'


triangleChartism: The world's first working-class movement

triangleYork Socialist Party: Engels' book 'Socialism - Scientific and Utopian'

triangleThe Communist Manifesto - A guide to understanding society, and how to change it


triangleBritain's economic growth figures mask fragile false recovery

triangleOxfam 'Inequality Kills' report


triangleHillingdon Socialist Party: The ideas of Leon Trotsky


triangleWest London Socialist Party: Dialectical materialism - a theory of change


triangleHackney & Islington Socialist Party: Marxism and Philosophy





Why are things the way they are?



The legacy of the collapse of Stalinism



Black history month and its relevance today



Can Biden reform the police?



A fighting programme for women's rights and socialism



'Casino capitalism' - driving another potential financial Armageddon


Communist Manifesto

The Communist Manifesto - A guide to understanding society, and how to change it



'Socialism - Utopian and Scientific' by Engels



Can green technology and AI save capitalism?



New pamphlet: constituent assemblies and the revolutionary programme



The striking relevance of Leon Trotsky's Theory of Permanent Revolution



200 years of Karl Marx: Marxist ideas more relevant than ever



Fighting the great tax robbery: taxes and regulation or socialist nationalisation?



Lenin's revolutionary legacy


Economic crisis

The Causes of Capitalist Crisis; Reply to Andrew Kliman

triangleMore Marxism articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777

Email: [email protected]

Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 079 8202 1969

East Mids: 077 3797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 078 4114 4890

North West 079 5437 6096

South West: 077 5979 6478

Southern: 078 3368 1910

Wales: 077 7221 5281

West Mids: 024 7655 5620

Yorkshire: 078 0983 9793



Alphabetical listing

June 2022

May 2022

April 2022

March 2022

February 2022

January 2022