Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 15 June 2006

Higher Education pay deal: Opportunities lost - further action can get more

LATE IN the evening on 6 June, negotiators for the newly formed University and College Union (UCU) reached a deal with the employers UCEA over pay in Higher Education.

Thomas House

The leadership of UCU has missed a significant opportunity by recommending this deal to members. Because action will be suspended while the ballot is taking place, members will be pushed by management into catching up on three months' marking over the next few weeks, in the knowledge that whatever the outcome of the ballot further action will have no effect until the next academic year.

There will be widespread anger that, just as the action was starting to bite, it was called off without adequate assurances about return to work, reversal of pay docking, and full implementation in every university.

There will be still more anger at the details of the offer, which falls far short of the initial claim of 23% over three years. UCEA's derisory 'last and final' offer of 12.6% over three years was rejected in May by union negotiators, and this decision was resoundingly supported at AUT and NATFHE's final conferences.

A more recent offer of 13.1% over three years was also rejected by negotiators, so it is surprising that the offer accepted is only roughly 10% over the next two years, with the UCU leadership arguing that they will be able to win a significantly better deal in the third year, when there will be three years of students paying top-up fees.

With Gordon Brown's talk of a public-sector pay freeze and likely increases in inflation over its current rate of 2.6%, this is unlikely to be possible without a fight.

This deal comes after three months of struggle, consisting of a one-day strike in March followed by an assessment boycott. While it is clear that UCEA were starting to move due to the action, opportunities to get a better deal were lost. It will be necessary to build further action in the next academic year.

Support for the unions had been growing steadily, partly due to the bullying anti-union tactics of many university managements and the intransigence of UCEA. This included docking pay of union members boycotting assessments, attempts to employ scab markers and revision of exam regulations in an attempt to break the action.

Membership increase

The action caused many to join the precursors to UCU - AUT and NATFHE - which were seen to be finally doing something about declining pay in universities.

Despite the predictable barrage of hostile media, which focused on students and commentators hostile to the unions' action, significant sections of students supported the action.

Particular credit must go to Socialist Students societies, which campaigned in support of the AUT and NATFHE even when their local student union was hostile.

Even some university staff too well-paid to benefit from any pay deal showed solidarity and undertook the assessment boycott.

Even Sally Hunt, one of the joint general secretaries of UCU, said in her email to members recommending the offer that the offer: "is not enough to show that the employers are finally treating you with the respect that you deserve".

More could have been won by continuing the action. UCU members should, therefore, reject the offer and plan to continue the dispute in the new academic year.

While many members are worn down by the pressures of the assessment boycott and are keen to end the dispute, there is no guarantee that employers will keep even their current meagre promises.

In fact, accepting the offer now will show weakness to university managements and encourage them to scupper the deal in local negotiations.

An emergency conference of UCU should be called after the summer break to plan future action. It will be necessary to re-evaluate the tactics used, since while an assessment boycott or other actions short of a strike can be useful, they are isolating and leave open greater possibilities for divide and rule between students and staff.

Future action must involve escalation of strike action. Actions short of a strike should include boycotts of management activities so that students do not feel victimised.

It is also vital to include students from the outset and link the demands for better pay not to the introduction of top up fees but to a united campaign against the privatisation of our universities.

The National Union of Students should be approached on strike days to organise a full higher education (HE) shutdown, demanding an end to fees, fair pay and conditions for university staff and no to cuts, closures and privatisation.

The HE attacks are just a part of New Labour's neo-liberal agenda in the public services. UCU urgently needs to start making links with other trade unions - a good start would be supporting the "Public Services not Private Profit" rally at Westminster on 27 June.

Vote 'no' in the ballot

SOCIALIST PARTY member Andrew Price, a member of the UCU NEC, told the socialist: "Working in and representing teaching staff in the further education sector I am concerned at this settlement as it has implications for all members of UCU.

"The negotiators were far too quick to grasp a slightly improved offer from the employers, ignoring the call for a special conference on the matter. In my view our members should vote 'no' in the ballot and through their branches demand a special conference in the autumn to plan a programme of escalating strike action to win the full claim."

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 15 June 2006:

Socialist Party NHS campaign

NHS protesters on the march

NHS: Rebellion over hospital cuts

Socialist Party campaigns

Victory for 'save our school' campaign

Anger mounting at bungled police raid

Tax credit system: Millions driven into debt

Socialist question time

World Cup: Profits and prostitution

Socialist Party review

1926 general strike debate

Why the BNP gets support: Naomi Byron reviews Fair by Joy Wilkinson

International socialist news and analysis

Stop Bush & Blair's terror

International students' movements and working class struggles

Palestinian authority on the brink of civil war?

Socialist Party workplace news

PCS conference a distinctive voice in the British trade union movement

Will UNISON fight on pensions and NHS cuts?

Higher Education pay deal: Opportunities lost - further action can get more


Home   |   The Socialist 15 June 2006   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleCarlisle election meeting: Education - time to make the mega-rich and corporations pay

triangleSave education - Kick out the Tories

triangleFighting for free education, jobs, homes, and a future worth living

triangleUCU votes for pay and pension strikes

triangleTrade unionists discuss climate change


triangleWestex Carpet strike reaches two month mark

triangleNorthern Ireland: Thousands of nurses continue to strike for better pay

triangleHackney school bus workers win pay increase following strikes

triangleLow Pay, Long Hours. Bosses rip us off. Organise the fightback now!


triangleUCU strikes: more determined than ever

triangleUni strike takes fight to bosses

trianglePay and pension strike: university staff have had enough


triangleYoung people who voted for Corbyn's manifesto will now ask... How can we win those ideas?

triangleClimate strikes: Students and trade unionists protest together


triangleUnion lawyer arrested on security guards' picket line


triangleFrench workers demonstrating in Paris on Thursday 16 January; Now over 40 days of strike action have taken place against the government's attacks on pensions. Photo James Ivens

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns


Young people

Young people who voted for Corbyn's manifesto will now ask... How can we win those ideas?



Massive Scottish independence demo marks new stage in struggle



London: Protesters return to oppose Middle East war



Cladding scandal: Government steps up defence of landlords



Nottingham: Youth protest against Barclays 64 million fossil-fuel investments



Westex Carpet strike reaches two month mark



Stop gentrification in Newham: "We are here, you have consulted us and we're not going anywhere!"


Socialist Party

Socialist Party national committee meeting



Hackney school bus workers win pay increase following strikes


Northern Ireland

Northern Ireland: Thousands of nurses continue to strike for better pay



London bus drivers ballot to strike



PCS: Time to rebuild the left



Union lawyer arrested on security guards' picket line



Unison national executive members challenge validity of nomination for Keir Starmer for leader of the Labour Party



Build union resistance to Tory attacks

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 079 8202 1969

East Mids: 077 3797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 078 4114 4890

North West 079 5437 6096

South West: 077 5979 6478

Southern: 078 3368 1910

Wales: 079 3539 1947

West Mids: 024 7655 5620

Yorkshire: 077 0671 0041



Alphabetical listing

January 2020