Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 28 February 2004

Education proposals: 

Back To The Future

MANY COMMENTATORS have welcomed the Tomlinson proposals to review the curriculum for 14-19 year olds. These will lead to a final report later in the year. Tomlinson advocates replacing GCSE and 'A' levels with a system of four diplomas - entry, foundation, intermediate and advanced - although not all pupils will have to take the first two.

Bob Sulatycki, National Union of Teachers (NUT)

Pupils will progress according to how they succeed, with the result that there will be many more mixed-age classes in secondary schools. The new arrangements are to be introduced over a 10-year period.

Critics from the union side have tended to focus on the upheaval that will be incurred, and the need for retraining of teachers, without addressing the underlying assumptions behind these very regressive reforms.

An editorial in the right-wing Daily Telegraph welcomes Tomlinson's "very good suggestions" and he himself has said that his proposals are in part a response to what employers want. We should not be surprised that a former deputy of Chris Woodhead in the schools inspection body OFSTED has come out with a thoroughly reactionary set of ideas.

The underlying motivations are to cut numbers (and thus costs) of students staying on at school, and of producing a workforce with the required low-level skills and flexibility for the low-wage economy for which they are to be prepared.

Tomlinson, hypocritically, cites pupil disaffection with the test-driven curriculum as a reason for introducing these changes. It is true that the exam-factory culture that has developed within schools over the past decade is an important reason for pupil disaffection.

Of course, OFSTED, under Tomlinson and Woodhead, has more responsibility than most for the promotion of this culture. The solution is to get rid of the tests - especially SATs, not to turn the clock back to the 1950s and before.

Funding shift

IT IS envisaged that pupils from the age of 14 will directed into a 'vocational route' outside the classroom for two days a week to learn a trade. One further day will be spent at college and the remaining two at school.

In a Daily Telegraph interview (21.2.04) Tomlinson said: "Junior apprenticeships could easily happen at 14". The hope is that the workplaces where they have been 'apprenticed' will take them on permanently at age 16.

This, and the fact that these pupils will, in effect, be barred from pursuing the higher-level diplomas, means that they will have their futures determined by age 14. It is, by stealth, a reduction of the school-leaving age to 14.

In addition, because schools will find it very difficult logistically and financially to offer the full range of diplomas, there will be a return - under a guise of specialisation - to the old pre-comprehensive tri-partite system of grammar, technical and secondary modern schools.

One net effect of the proposals will be a massive funding shift out of schools, with an attendant loss of staffing. This will be further accentuated by the admission from Tomlinson that thousands of pupils will now not reach the standards necessary to meet the qualifications needed to continue education to the higher-level diploma. The numbers continuing to the higher-level diploma (in effect the replacement for 'A' levels) will be drastically reduced.

Tomlinson echoes the right-wing educationalists who want to deny access to the rooms at the top for the increasing numbers of students who seek their place there.

Education unions, parents and students must campaign against the implementation of the Tomlinson proposals. In its place socialists will campaign for a broad balanced curriculum, where pupils can follow a full range of subjects; technical, artistic and academic, free from the treadmill of never ending tests.

But to make it interesting and relevant means having schools properly resourced, with reduced class size, additional support staffing, books, computers, access to playing space and sports fields. Finally, and importantly, we continue to campaign against the poverty and inequality which forces millions of working class pupils to fail to fulfil their potential in the current educational system.

No To Commercialisation And Privatisation

THE GOVERNMENT are continuingly making cuts to our education. The Tomlinson report is clearly linked to making more money out of education by allowing big business to 'invest' in it. These proposals and others, such as top-up fees, have very little to do with providing a decent education and future for people.

New Labour and their big business friends are only interested in offering young people low-skilled, low-paid work and think they can take us back to the days when working-class young people were forced to leave school at 14 to work.

International Socialist Resistance (ISR) is campaigning against this and the commercialisation and privatisation of our education. We need more teachers, smaller class sizes and the right to learn throughout our lives, for the benefit of society - not for big business.

We demand:

  • Big business out of education.
  • No to the commercialisation and privatisation of education.
  • Scrap tuition fees - no to top-up fees and a graduate tax.
  • For a free quality education, decent job and proper training for all.
  • Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

    In The Socialist 28 February 2004:

    Global Warning

    "We'll protect our homes"

    EU Enlargement Brings Benefits For The Bosses

    Workers Must Fight Attacks On Democratic Rights

    University strike: Why Cardiff closed down

    Back To The Future

    Socialist Party workplace news and analysis

    Fighting The Bosses And The BNP

    When Workers Beat The Heath Government

    Gershon's "Cunning Plan" For The Public Sector

    International socialist news and analysis

    World Currencies - Turbulent Times Ahead?

    Netherlands: Government Scapegoats Asylum Seekers

    Pakistan: Workers Fight Musharraf's Regime


    Home   |   The Socialist 28 February 2004   |   Join the Socialist Party

    Subscribe   |   Donate  

    Related links:


    triangleMoney doesn't make up for cuts - education unions must organise for funding and against Tory attacks

    triangleLeicestershire - No more austerity!

    triangleNEU conference: organise for the key battles to come

    triangleGovernment fails to deliver on funding and teachers' pay - demand action to win 5%

    triangleNEU conference: Teachers vote to strike over pay and workload


    triangleCarlisle election meeting: Education - time to make the mega-rich and corporations pay

    triangleSave education - Kick out the Tories

    triangleFighting for free education, jobs, homes, and a future worth living

    triangleUCU votes for pay and pension strikes


    triangleThe Socialist Inbox

    triangleIlford: parents and teachers unite against school cuts

    triangleAcademy strike - standing up to 'bullying' management forces climbdown


    triangleNEU support staff dismiss Tory 'extra funding' hype

    triangleLabour votes to abolish academies and private schools


    triangleBrighton anti-academy campaign steps up

    Big business:

    triangleKshama Sawant reelected in Seattle

    Reports and campaigns

    Reports and campaigns



    Swansea: Corbyn rally attracts turnout but many can't get in


    Socialist Party

    Fight for your future - join the socialists



    Strikes: more determined than ever


    Socialist Students

    Students and workers united in struggle


    South Western Railway

    It's a strike to ensure the safety of the travelling public



    Surrey firefighters to ballot on Christmas industrial action



    Social workers lobby Hull City Council


    Climate change

    Climate strikes: Students and trade unionists protest together


    Socialist Party

    Why I joined: "Proud to be a socialist"



    Carlisle election meeting: Education - time to make the mega-rich and corporations pay



    Workplace news in brief


    West Midlands

    Solid support for guards on West Midlands Trains


    Climate change

    Climate change election debate - Corbyn offers best green solutions but needs to go further


    The Socialist

    Selling the Socialist


    Royal Mail

    Royal Mail court ruling - national reps meeting and solidarity action essential

    triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

    Join the Socialist Party
    Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
    Donate to the Socialist Party
    Socialist Party Facebook page
    Socialist Party on Twitter
    Visit us on Youtube



    Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


    Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

    Regional Socialist Party organisers:

    Eastern: 0798 202 1969

    East Mids: 0773 797 8057

    London: 020 8988 8786

    North East: 0784 114 4890

    North West 07954 376 096

    South East: 020 8988 8777

    South West: 07759 796 478

    Southern: 07833 681910

    Wales: 07935 391 947

    West Mids: 02476 555 620

    Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



    Alphabetical listing

    December 2019

    November 2019

    October 2019

    September 2019

    August 2019

    July 2019

    June 2019

    May 2019

    April 2019

    March 2019

    February 2019

    January 2019