Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 10 June 2009

Labour in meltdown

Step up the fight for a new workers' party

The outcome of the county council elections, followed by the 'meltdown' in the European elections, was a devastating defeat for New Labour and the Gordon Brown dominated government. The scale of Labour's collapse is indicated by its share of the popular vote of under 16%, the lowest since 1910 when it scored 7.6%!

Peter Taaffe, Socialist Party general secretary

Brown's government, and with it New Labour, is in terminal decline. There is not an atom of real politics in the vicious and brutal clash between Brown and his opponents.

It is a naked attempt by Brown to hold on and a naked lust for power by a motley array of his opponents, odious careerists, most of them from a Blairite background.

Stephen Byers, acolyte of Tony Blair, declared that the parliamentary Labour Party must decide whether "Gordon Brown is a winner or a loser". Moreover, he says, for Labour MPs, the present crisis is a 'P45 moment' (the P45 is a tax form that is effectively seen as redundancy notice).

Two million unemployed workers have already received their P45 and another million or million and a half wait in line for the same fate. It is not this that concerns Byers but whether Brown can 'win' for the MPs - not the working class - or whether these MPs themselves will be made 'redundant' in a general election.

However, what concerns the Socialist Party and working-class people in Britain is how best to defend the interests, wages and conditions of the mass of the working class. New Labour has demonstrated again and again - underlined once more in these elections - that it cannot fulfil this task.

The Tories, so confident of winning a general election, already openly 'confess' that they will launch an attack on the living standards of the working class when they come to power. George Osborne, prospective Tory Chancellor of the Exchequer, boasted to 'business leaders': "After three months in power we will be the most unpopular government since the war".

Brown is incapable of stopping this nightmarish prospect. He is so weak in the aftermath of these elections that he is unable to select his own cabinet, with ministers, in effect, 'reshuffling themselves'. Alan Johnson, the 'prince over the water', has been imprisoned in the cabinet.

If Brown goes on to face a catastrophic general election as the leader, it is because Labour MPs have no real alternative and have resigned themselves to electoral wipe-out.

What happens to a motley crew of New Labour careerists is secondary to working-class people. What concerns them is the attacks which have been carried out, and the more horrendous ones that are coming from the capitalist parties. A fighting leadership in the unions and a new mass political party, with a bold leadership, is needed.

Potential, and need, for workers' alternative

In the European election New Labour was beaten into third place nationally by the UK Independence Party (Ukip - 'the BNP in blazers'). In Scotland the Scottish National Party, for the first time in a UK-wide election, outscored New Labour. In the formerly Labour bastion of Wales, Labour was beaten into second place by the Tories for the first time since 1918. Labour was relegated to fifth place in the South-East and South West of England by the Greens, and came sixth in Cornwall, behind the Cornish nationalists!

The increase for Ukip - pushing Labour into third position nationally - and, particularly, the two seats won by the odious British National Party's Nick Griffin and his partner in crime, Andrew Brons, was a sickening spectacle to those workers and young people who viewed it on television at the time and afterwards.

But, contrary to the impression that could be given, these results were not a resounding victory for the 'right'. Support for Ukip, but particularly the BNP, arose from the collapse, in the main, of the New Labour vote. As the BBC news website comments: "They actually got fewer votes in the North-West and Yorkshire and the Humber this time than in 2004." The same applies to the Tories who, in effect, flatlined with their vote no higher than in 2004 and well down on the 36% William Hague scored in 1999.


The Greens scored a big increase in votes but with no increase in their MEPs because of the biased electoral system in Britain which is unfair to small parties. If the vote for the BNP represents a protest to the 'right', the Greens, in the main, are a 'left' protest vote and, paradoxically, are an indication of the potential for a new mass workers' party. However, the Greens have not yet been fully tested out in action, apart from in some councils where they have been found wanting. In Ireland, they have been decimated - payment by voters for sharing power in the right-wing dominated Fianna Fáil government. Fianna Fáil received its lowest vote since the state was founded.

These elections reveal both the fragmentation and confusion in the outlook of millions of workers repulsed by the 'mainstream' pro-capitalist parties, and who are casting around wildly for an alternative. Hence the vote for parties based on religion, and for an exclusively Tamil candidate in London, which represented an appeal to 'ethnicity'. If this became the trend, it would be grist to the mill of the far-right in trying to generate a 'white backlash', which was evident in Griffin's rant on BBC TV on the night of the count.

This feature - a scattered consciousness and, therefore, disjointed electoral protests - is evident also to some extent in the results of the EU elections in Europe. For instance, the 'Pirate Party' - so named because of the pirating of music on the internet - received 9% of the vote in Sweden! But the erratic voting patterns in Europe do not substantiate the arguments of commentators in Britain that the continent 'lurched to the right', that the 'centre-right' came out victorious in these elections. Most of the right-wing capitalist parties - Angela Merkel in Germany, Nicolas Sarkozy in France or even Silvio Berlusconi in Italy - merely held on to their previous voting percentages or 'flatlined', while the percentage of the vote to their opponents decreased.

In Germany, Merkel's Christian Democracy suffered a big drop in votes, but the Social Democrats - who share power with them - polled less (see page 6). Without a clear, mass left alternative being offered, and despite the catastrophic economic situation which was a fundamental and determining element in the background of this election, many acquiesced to 'nanny', to right-wing governments and parties. Others, in sheer desperation, were seduced by the far-right, including by Ukip in Britain.

But this did not happen in Ireland because, among other things, there was the splendid campaign of Joe Higgins, under the banner of the Irish Socialist Party, who received a magnificent 13% of first preference votes and was elected to the European parliament on an unambiguous socialist ticket. This was probably the best vote for a clear left-wing socialist candidate in Europe.

Other left parties gained. But Joe's Socialist Party victory was achieved on the basis of an exemplary fighting programme in the election, but also on the back of the tremendous record of fighting the anti-water privatisation campaign, against bin charges and Joe's subsequent jailing. Also there was his crucial involvement in the extra-parliamentary battles of the Irish working class, notably Gama and the Irish Ferries dispute.

Set against the organic corruption of the Irish political elite, Joe's honesty, his refusal to take more than the average wage of a worker, and clear radical and socialist policies stood out. No possibility here for the far-right to make gains. Nor in Germany, where the Left Party (Die Linke), despite its weaknesses in programme and structure, was an electoral obstacle on a national level stopping workers swinging to the far right in protest against the pro-capitalist parties. Unfortunately, no clear pole of attraction of this character exists in most of the countries in Europe.


A heroic effort was made in this election by the No2EU-Yes to Democracy campaign. Unfortunately, the time between establishing the campaign and the election was too short to attract substantial sections of the trade unions and the labour movement to its banner. This meant that it could not stamp its political imprint on the consciousness of workers - who it was aimed at - thereby overcoming, partially at least, the confused political situation.

Nevertheless, it was absolutely correct for the Socialist Party, the RMT and the Communist Party of Britain (CPB) to seize the opportunity to create a workers' bloc as a rallying point for all those repelled by New Labour and looking for a means of striking back against the British and European bosses. The programme was limited - determined by the very nature of a bloc - but its significance lay in the fact that it was the first challenge made by a national trade union, in collaboration with others on the left, to the Labour Party since its inception.

It would therefore seem natural that those on the left who had been struggling for an independent political force to the left of Labour would welcome and support this development. But, incredibly, some on the left opted for supporting New Labour or the Greens in some areas. Yet this election indicated clearly that it was the demonstrable feeling in solid working-class areas - pit villages in Yorkshire, as Griffin jeered on the television - which felt most let down by New Labour. Therefore, in desperation, some voted for the BNP. So some on the left, in a campaign 'to oppose the BNP', urge a vote for the very people who have created the conditions which have allowed these creatures to grow and prosper!

No2EU-Yes to Democracy was a credible working-class alternative to New Labour. A bigger vote would have been welcome (see page 5). But the combined vote for No2EU and the Socialist Labour Party indicates the possibility of a united socialist campaign. No2EU's real importance, however, lay in the fact that it stepped outside the framework of an atrophied Labour Party to offer an alternative. No new force can establish itself overnight. Why should working people, disappointed in previous support for 'new' organisations, immediately transfer their hopes to a new organisation, particularly given the virtual media black-out?

The charge that the Socialist Party lent itself to nationalist propaganda in this campaign is entirely false. Firstly, the programme is a basic class opposition to the EU and an appeal for "international workers' solidarity". Secondly, complementing the official campaign, the Socialist Party circulated socialist leaflets independently which put the case for class opposition to the BNP and the Lisbon treaty, and for an international socialist appeal for a united socialist states of Europe.

Given the grave threat to the working class of Britain - symbolised in the attacks by the Lindsey oil refinery bosses, at Visteon and elsewhere - it was the bounden duty of socialists to try to create a fighting, working-class alternative, no matter how limited this was. Moreover, those efforts have to be stepped up to provide an alternative in the forthcoming general election, when the same variety of brands of capitalist 'soap powder' - parties that stand within the framework of capitalism - will be once more on offer.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 10 June 2009:

Step up the fight for a new workers' party

A socialist MEP Joe Higgins elected in Ireland

'The best fighter that money can't buy'

STOP PRESS: BNP feel the anger

Youth Fight against Racism

Socialist Party election campaign analysis

No2EU: a step towards a workers' political voice

Socialist Party workplace news

Reinstate Rob Williams now! Support Linamar strikers

London Underground: Solidarity with strike over jobs and pay

Glasgow council street cleaners start workers' fightback

Bristol bins strike threat brings new conditions offer

Unison NEC elections bring gains for Socialist Party

Another DWP minister resigns

Engineering construction workers ballot: End 'race to the bottom'

Come to NSSN conference

News in brief

Socialist Party publication

The Masses Arise: The French revolution and today's struggles

International socialist news and analysis

European parliament elections 2009: Europe on the edge

General strike in Basque country

Brazil: "Liberty, Socialism and Revolution" is born

Youth fight for jobs

CWU conference backs Youth Fight for Jobs campaign

No to cuts at Kings

Liverpool Community College strike


Home   |   The Socialist 10 June 2009   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


trianglePCS union - A reply on political strategy

triangleTony Mulhearn 1939-2019: Courageous fighter for the working class and socialism

triangleMass union mobilisation needed to counter anti-choice group

triangleCorbyn must stand firm against establishment and Labour right

triangleLabour and the fight for a shorter working week


triangle40 years on: Mandatory reselection more vital for Labour than ever

triangleTories in tatters: Corbyn must seize the time

triangleTories in tatters: Corbyn must seize the time

triangleBoot out Boris and all the Tories


triangleVote for socialist fighter Jared Wood in RMT elections

triangleFar right makes gains in Germany

triangleGreece elections: Syriza ousted amid voter disillusionment


triangleRMT: Jared Wood - Fighting cuts, defending jobs, pay and conditions

triangleGeneral secretary election: Marion Lloyd - standing for action on members' pay, jobs, pensions and more

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns


Postal workers

Massive vote for strike action: - "We're out to win!"



General secretary election: Marion Lloyd - standing for action on members' pay, jobs, pensions and more


Socialist Party

Be part of the future: join the Socialist Party


Waltham Forest

Mass union mobilisation needed to counter anti-choice group


Campaign Opposing Police Surveillance

Pressure needed to force secret police disclosure


Climate change

Trade unionists discuss climate change


National Education Union

NEU support staff dismiss Tory 'extra funding' hype



Hackney SEND transport workers achieve victory



RMT: Jared Wood - Fighting cuts, defending jobs, pay and conditions



Wales: Hundreds march to save the Orb works



Flooring workers strike, Derbyshire



Attacks on Caerphilly waste management workers



BEIS: Outsourced caterers' indefinite strike victory



York freshers success



'The little people can win' - Leeds tenants push back demolition

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07954 376 096

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

October 2019

September 2019

August 2019

July 2019

June 2019

May 2019

April 2019

March 2019

February 2019

January 2019